Introducing: Book month
October 2026 is declared Book Month for the Garden Collective. As an online publisher of fine words about gardens and gardening, James is here to explain why nothing will ever replace the real thing.
There are an awful lot of garden books out there. I own a couple of hundred, but I am pretty sure that is a modest collection and that there are many others whose libraries are on a much larger scale.
Mine is modest partly because I ruthlessly culled a lot of them when we moved house a few years ago, and I don't have the shelf space to keep up with new publications. Not that I particularly need to, as I seldom consult the books I own, let alone read new ones. I think the last garden book I read from cover to cover was the excellent Diary of a Keen Gardener by Mary Keen.
It was not always thus. When I first started gardening, my constant companions were the Reader's Digest book of plants, the Reader's Digest book of DIY (which taught me how to lay bricks) and the RHS Encyclopedia of Garden Plants (which I still have). All of these books are pretty much pointless in this day and age. We have phones that can identify plants for us, and an internet that will give you more information than you could ever find in a couple of inches of caption. Is this a sad thing? Not really: it is an example of how lucky we are to live and garden in an age of easily accessed information.
Another thing that hit the recycling bin when we moved was every single copy of Gardens Illustrated, going back to Issue One, published in 1993. Out of interest, that first issue included tips from Rosemary Alexander on building a path, a romp round the colour borders at Hadspen (now The Newt) with Sandra and Nori Pope (photographed by the great Andrew Lawson), Beth Chatto on fritillaries and a feature on garden tools. In her editor's letter, Rosie Atkins says she is pleased to launch a new magazine "in an age when gardening seems to offer attractive alternatives to the harsh realities of life". Nothing really changes! We said much the same thing when we launched The Garden Collective a couple of years ago.
Like us, Gardens Illustrated was a breath of fresh air when it launched, but now, thirty-something years later, the early issues are more museum pieces than a resource. They looked lovely on the shelf, but I was never going to go back and read a copy from 1998, so I binned them all (except Issue One, which I kept as a curio).
The books I read in those days that have kept some relevance include The Education of a Gardener by Russell Page (my copy has a large cigarette burn on page twelve – it is probably best not to speculate why), Robin Lane Fox's Thoughtful Gardening and Christopher Lloyd's The Adventurous Gardener.
These days I just pluck the odd book from the passing torrent of new publications. My most recent was Mary Keen's, and I loved Pastoral Gardens by Clare Foster. I want something I can read on a train and enjoy as much as a novel.
It seems the world of books has changed a great deal in the age of social media. This was foretold by Dr David Hessayon (about whom both Matt Pottage and my friend Joe Swift will write this month) in his speech at the 2013 Garden Media Guild awards, where he warned that the internet would kill off experts, and he seems to have been right. Many of the garden books published nowadays are written by enthusiastic people with large social media followings. Most of them are lovely, excitable people, but they are by no means experienced gardeners.
I am not their market. Most of these books are aimed at novice gardeners and, if they encourage people to take up gardening, that is great, but they offer little to gardeners who are getting the hang of things and want to go a bit deeper. There are only so many times we need to be told that mulching is good and that taking lavender cuttings is easy (and cheaper than buying plants).
I am sure publishers will keep producing them and people will keep buying them. There will be glorious coffee-table books with wonderful photographs but words that few people will read, and even more how-to books that will be given away as Christmas presents.
Feel like there needs to be a bridging para here which says something about how tGC is an alternative to all of those things but also that there are books still to celebrate? Sort of lands as all books these days are by influencers and photographers...
This month at The Garden Collective is dedicated to books, with author interviews, conversations, recommendations and inspiration. Something for all of you…

